Cross-section of the management system standards in the folder
The sources are the PDFs in the working folder. These texts compare them. They do not pull the requirements together into one common set of…
Read articleAcross the management system standards
For: V, IA
Source: ISO 9001:2026, 0.1, 3.10, 7.5 and A.2 e. ISO 14001:2026, 7.5 and A.2, A.3, A.7.5. ISO 45001:2018, 7.5 and A.3 f, A.7.5. ISO/IEC 27001:2022, 7.5. ISO/IEC 42001:2023, 7.5.
7.5 has the same structure in the five standards. 7.5.1 says what the system includes. 7.5.2 says what shall be ensured when creating and updating. 7.5.3 says how the information is to be controlled. The wording is not the same in every sentence.
What 7.5.1 requires in all five. The system shall include the documented information that the document requires, and the documented information that the organization determines to be necessary for effectiveness. The note says that the extent can differ from organization to organization. "Can". The reasons named are not the same everywhere.
ISO 9001, ISO/IEC 27001 and ISO/IEC 42001 name three reasons: the size of the organization and the nature of its activities, processes, products and services; the complexity of the processes and their interactions; the competence of persons.
ISO 14001 names the same three and, in addition, the need to demonstrate fulfilment of the compliance obligations. Competence relates to persons who carry out work under the organization's control.
ISO 45001 names the three reasons, the need to demonstrate fulfilment of legal requirements and other requirements, and the competence of workers. "Workers", in the German text Beschäftigte.
What 7.5.2 requires in all five. Appropriate identification and description, for example title, date, author or reference number. Appropriate format, for example language, software version or graphics, and medium, for example paper or electronic. Review and approval for suitability and adequacy.
What 7.5.3 requires in all five. The documented information required shall be controlled so that it is available and suitable for use where and when it is needed, and so that it is adequately protected. The examples name loss of confidentiality, improper use and loss of integrity. Where applicable, the organization shall address: distribution, access, retrieval and use; storage and preservation, including legibility; control of changes, for example version control; retention and disposition. "As applicable". In ISO 9001 this means, according to A.2, that a requirement can be determined as not applicable in individual situations, even if under 4.3 it applies in general. The other four standards do not contain this sentence of the reading key at this place. Documented information of external origin that the organization determines to be necessary for planning and operation shall be appropriately identified and controlled. The English wording is "identified as appropriate, and controlled" or, in ISO 9001 and ISO/IEC 42001, "identified as appropriate and controlled". The note says that access can mean only the permission to read, or the permission and authority to read and to change. "Can".
Differences in 7.5.3 and alongside. ISO 9001 divides the control into 7.5.3.1 and 7.5.3.2. The same place additionally requires that documented information available as evidence of conformity be protected against unintended changes. 7.5.3 of ISO 14001, ISO 45001, ISO/IEC 27001 and ISO/IEC 42001 does not contain this sentence. ISO 45001, Note 2 to 7.5.3, says that access to relevant documented information includes the access of workers and, where they exist, of their representatives.
ISO 9001, 0.1, says that the document requires neither a uniform structure of quality management systems, nor documentation that follows the clause structure, nor the use of the standard's terms in operation. A.2 repeats this as guidance. ISO 14001, A.2, says as guidance that there is no requirement to apply the clause structure or the terminology to the system or to its documentation. A.7.5 says as guidance that the documented information need not take the form of a manual. ISO/IEC 27001, clause 7, and ISO/IEC 42001, 7.5, do not require a manual under a particular title. The order of the requirements, which ISO/IEC 27001, 0.1, and ISO/IEC 42001 in the introduction separate from importance and from the sequence of implementation, is a different sentence from the sentence on documentation structure in ISO 9001, 0.1.
ISO 9001, A.2 e, distinguishes two formulations. "Shall be available as documented information" means the availability of information that the organization obtains, uses or provides. "Documented information shall be available as evidence of" means the retention of objective evidence. According to that, "as evidence of" does not mean legal requirements of proof. ISO 14001, A.3, explains the corresponding change compared with the earlier edition and remains informative. ISO 45001, A.3 f, keeps two verbs apart in the German. "Als dokumentierte Information aufrechterhalten" refers to documents. "Aufbewahren dokumentierter Information als Nachweis" refers to records. The formulation as evidence is not intended as a requirement for legal certainty. Where a clause requires both verbs, both remain.
Which clause requires which documented information is set out in the article on the clause: 9001-14, 14001-11, 45001-08, 27001-07, 27001-12, 42001-08.
Documented information: 7.5 is the rule for which information the system includes and how it is controlled. 7.2 of the five standards additionally requires evidence of competence, each in the wording of that standard.
Not in this text: a control system in the form of a template, a retention period, and the statement that the five versions of 7.5 are the same word for word. ISO 10013 is named in ISO 9001 and is not available.