Explanations of ISO/IEC 42001:2023
Source is ISO/IEC 42001:2023(en). Title: Information technology — Artificial intelligence — Management system. It was prepared by the joint…
Read articleISO/IEC 42001:2023
For: V
Source: ISO/IEC 42001:2023(en), English. A.8, B.8
The control objective A.8 is to ensure that relevant interested parties have the information necessary to understand and assess risks and their positive and negative impacts. Four reference controls, to the extent necessary.
A.8.2: determine and provide the information necessary for users of the AI system.
A.8.3: provide means so that interested parties can report adverse impacts of the AI system.
A.8.4: determine and document a plan for communicating incidents to the users of the AI system.
A.8.5: determine and document the organization’s own obligations to report information about the AI system to interested parties.
B.8 uses “should”. B.8.2 says that information can comprise technical details, instructions and notices that someone is interacting with an AI system, including for outputs. Users need to be able to understand when they are interacting with an AI system and how it works, and they need to understand the purpose, the intended uses and the potential for harm or benefit. The “need to” stands in the guidance, not as an additional “shall” beside A.8.2. Information should be accessible. What can be provided includes, among other things, the purpose, the notice of interaction with AI, the type of interaction, how and when the system is overridden, technical requirements and limits, human oversight, accuracy and performance, relevant results of the impact assessment, changes and a contact. Criteria for whether and what is provided should be documented. The organization should verify that users have access and that the information is complete, up to date and accurate.
B.8.3: operation should be monitored for problems that are reported, and the organization should offer means to report adverse impacts, as an example unfairness. That is guidance beside A.8.3. The reporting of concerns within the organization is A.3.3, see 42001-12. The two are not the same process.
B.8.4: incidents can concern the AI system itself, or information security or privacy, as an example a breach of the protection of data. The organization should understand its notification obligations. Legal requirements and regulation can prescribe types of incidents, time limits, authorities and the content. The organization can integrate the reporting into the wider incident management, but should know requirements that are peculiar to AI or to individual components. ISO/IEC 27001 and ISO/IEC 27701 are named for incident management relating to security and privacy. ISO/IEC 27701 is not available. ISO/IEC 27001:2022 is in the working folder, but is not read into control A.8.4 here. A.8.4 does not say which time limit applies.
B.8.5: a jurisdiction can require that information is shared with authorities. What can be shared includes technical documentation, risks, results of impact assessments and logs. The organization should understand its obligations. The section presupposes that the organization knows legal requirements on the exchange of information with law enforcement authorities. That is guidance, not a particular legal act.
Not in this text: user information as a template, a reporting time limit, and a commentary on a concrete obligation to provide information to an authority. A.8.5 requires the organization’s own obligations to be determined and documented, to the extent the control is necessary. Clause 10 addresses the nonconformity, not the incident towards users.