logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

ISO/IEC 17021-1

17021-13 How an audit proceeds

6 min read · V, EA

All articles

For: V, EA
Source: 9.4.1 to 9.4.8, 3.11 to 3.13

The body shall have a process for on-site audits, with an opening meeting at the beginning and a closing meeting at the end. Where a part is carried out by electronic means, or the place is virtual, persons with appropriate competence shall carry out these activities. The evidence shall be sufficient for the auditor, knowing the facts, to be able to take a reasoned decision on conformity with the requirement in question. A note: “on site” can include remote access to electronic locations that contain information relevant to the audit. Audits by electronic means can also be taken into consideration.

Opening

An official opening meeting takes place with the client's management and, where applicable, with the persons responsible for the functions or processes being audited. The team leader usually conducts it. The level of detail depends on the client's familiarity with the audit process. The following shall be taken into account: introduction of the participants and of their roles; confirmation of the scope of certification; confirmation of the plan, of the type of audit, of the scope, the objectives and the criteria, of any changes, and of arrangements such as the time of the closing meeting and of interim meetings; the official channels of communication; resources and facilities; confidentiality; occupational health and safety, emergency arrangements and safety for the team; the availability, roles and identities of guides and observers; the reporting and the classification of findings; conditions that can lead to the audit being broken off early; the responsibility of the team leader and of the team, representing the body, for the audit and for directing the execution of the plan; the status of earlier findings, where applicable; the sampling methods; the language of the audit; keeping the client informed on an ongoing basis about progress and about problems; the opportunity for the client to ask questions.

During the audit

The team evaluates progress at regular intervals and exchanges information. The team leader reassigns tasks where needed and keeps the client regularly informed of progress and of concerns.

Where the evidence shows that the objectives cannot be achieved, or where an immediate and considerable risk can exist, for example to safety, the team leader shall report to the client and, if possible, to the body, so that measures are determined. These can include reconfirming or changing the plan, changes to the objectives or to the scope, or breaking the audit off. The results of the measures shall be reported to the body. A need to change the scope that becomes apparent on site is examined by the team leader together with the client, and is reported to the body.

Information that is significant for the objectives, the scope and the criteria, including the interfaces between functions, activities and processes, shall be collected by appropriate sampling and verified, so that it constitutes audit evidence. Methods for obtaining information shall include at least interviews, observation of processes and activities, and review of documentation and records.

Findings

Findings that summarize conformities and describe nonconformities in detail shall be identified, classified and recorded, so that a decision can be taken on the basis of information, or so that the certification can be maintained. Opportunities for improvement may be identified and recorded, unless the certification scheme prohibits that. Nonconformities may not be recorded as opportunities for improvement.

A nonconformity is the non-fulfilment of a requirement. It shall be recorded against a specific requirement and shall contain a clear statement that describes the objective evidence in detail. It shall be discussed with the client, so that the evidence is accurate and the nonconformity is understood. The auditor shall refrain from proposing causes or solutions.

The team leader shall try to resolve disagreements between the team and the client about the evidence or the findings. Unresolved points shall be recorded.

Conclusions and closing

Before the closing meeting, the team, under the responsibility of the team leader, shall review the findings and the other appropriate information against the objectives and the criteria, and shall classify the nonconformities; shall draw the conclusions together, taking into account the uncertainty of the audit process; shall agree on any follow-up measures that are required; and shall confirm the suitability of the programme or identify changes that are needed for future audits, for example the scope, the audit time, the time period, the frequency of surveillance, or the competence of the team.

The official closing meeting takes place with the management and, where applicable, with the persons responsible for the functions audited. Attendance shall be recorded. The purpose is to present the conclusions, including the recommendation regarding certification. All nonconformities shall be presented in such a way that they are understood, and a time frame for the response to them shall be agreed. A note says that “understood” does not mean that the client also accepts them.

In addition, again at the level of detail appropriate to the familiarity: an indication that the evidence is based on a sample and therefore contains an element of uncertainty; the method and the time frame of reporting, including the classification; the body's process for dealing with nonconformities and the consequences for the certification status; the time frame within which the client shall present a plan for corrections and corrective actions on the nonconformities identified; the subsequent activities of the body; information on complaints and appeals. The client may ask questions. Disagreements about findings or conclusions shall be discussed and, where possible, resolved. Unresolved points shall be recorded and passed on to the body.

Report

A written report for the client shall be prepared for every audit. The team may point out opportunities for improvement, but may not recommend specific solutions. Ownership of the report remains with the body. The team leader ensures that the report is produced and bears the responsibility for its content. The report shall be an accurate, concise and clear record, so that a decision on the basis of information is possible. It shall contain the following, or refer to it:

  • the body;
  • the name and address of the client and of the client's representative;
  • the type of audit;
  • the criteria, the objectives and the scope, in particular the organizational units or processes audited, and the audit time;
  • any deviations from the plan, and the reasons for them;
  • significant matters that influence the programme;
  • the team leader, the team members and accompanying persons;
  • the dates and places, whether on site or not, and whether the sites are permanent or temporary;
  • the findings, the reference to the evidence, and conclusions appropriate to the type of audit;
  • significant changes to the system since the last audit, where there are any;
  • unresolved matters, where any have been identified;
  • where applicable, whether the audit was combined, joint or integrated;
  • a disclaimer that the auditing is based on a sample of the information available;
  • the recommendation of the team;
  • where applicable, that the client effectively controls the use of documents and of marks;
  • where applicable, verification of the effectiveness of corrective actions on earlier nonconformities.

In addition: a statement on conformity and on effectiveness, with a summary of the evidence of the ability to fulfil applicable requirements and to deliver the expected results, and of the internal audit process and the management review; a finding on the suitability of the scope; confirmation that the audit objectives were achieved.

Not in this text: wording templates for nonconformities, or a classification of its own beside “major” and “minor”. How the body classifies shall fit 3.12 and 3.13. The auditor names the evidence and the requirement that was not fulfilled, and proposes neither a cause nor a solution.