logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

ISO/IEC 17021-1

17021-03 Impartiality, consultancy, liability

6 min read · EA, V

All articles

For: EA, V
Source: 3.3, 4.2, 5.1.1, 5.1.2, 5.2, 5.3, 6.1, 6.2

Impartiality is the presence of objectivity. Objectivity means that conflicts of interest do not exist or have been resolved, so that subsequent activities of the body are not adversely affected. Related words that the note to the term names include, among others, independence, neutrality, fairness and keeping one's distance. These are explanations of the term, not additional checkpoints.

Legal entity and contract

The body shall be a legal entity, or a defined part of a legal entity, that can be held legally responsible for all certification activities. A governmental body is deemed a legal entity on the basis of its status as an authority.

There shall be a legally enforceable agreement with every client for the certification activities, consistent with the requirements of this part. Where the body has several branches or the client has several sites, the agreement between the body that grants the certificate and the client shall cover all sites within the scope. A note permits several agreements that refer to one another to carry this result.

What the body shall do on an ongoing basis

Conformity assessment shall be carried out impartially. The body is responsible for that and may not allow commercial, financial or other pressure. Top management shall commit itself to impartiality. There shall be a policy that states the understanding of impartiality, the handling of conflicts of interest and the safeguarding of objectivity.

There shall be a process that continually identifies, analyses, evaluates, treats, monitors and documents risks relating to conflicts of interest, including conflicts arising from relationships with related bodies. Where a threat is identified, it shall be documented and demonstrated how it is eliminated, and every residual risk shall be documented. The demonstration covers all identified potential threats, whether they arise within the body or from other persons, bodies or organizations. Top management shall assess whether a residual risk lies within an acceptable degree.

A relationship that constitutes a threat that is not acceptable precludes the certification. The standard's example: a wholly owned subsidiary requires its parent company, which is the certification body, to provide a certification. That certification may not be provided.

The risk assessment shall name suitable interested parties and consult them on matters that concern confidence in impartiality, including openness and public perception. The consultation shall be balanced. Individual interests may not predominate. A note names a committee of these parties as one way. That is an example, not an obligation to use the legal form “committee”. Further notes name possible causes (ownership, governance, management, personnel, shared resources, finances, contracts, training, marketing, sales commissions) and possible parties (personnel, clients, their customers, associations, authorities, non-governmental organizations including consumer organizations).

All internal and external personnel and all committees that could have an influence on the certification activities shall act impartially. Personnel shall disclose every known situation that could place them or the body in a conflict of interest. The body shall record this and derive threats from it. It may use the person only where it can demonstrate that no conflict of interest exists. It shall respond to threats arising from the activities of other persons, bodies or organizations.

Consultancy is something narrow, and that is exactly what is prohibited

Management system consultancy is participation in establishing, implementing or maintaining a management system. Examples in the definition: preparing or producing manuals or procedures; giving specific advice, instructions or solutions for development and implementation.

Training, and acting as a trainer, are not regarded as consultancy where the training on management systems or on auditing remains limited to general information. The trainer should not offer client-specific solutions. General information without client-specific solutions for improvement is also not consultancy. The note counts the following as part of this: explaining the sense and purpose of the certification requirements; identifying opportunities for improvement; explaining related theories, methods, techniques or tools; sharing non-confidential information on related proven practice; other management aspects that the audited system does not cover. Exchange of information between the body and the client, for example explaining findings or clarifying requirements, remains permissible according to the note to 5.2.5.

The body, parts of the same legal entity and any entity under its organizational control may not offer or provide management system consultancy. This also applies to the part of a governmental body that is designated as the certification body. The same group may not offer or provide internal audits to certified clients. That would be a significant threat through self-review. A recognized minimization: the body certifies a management system for which it has carried out internal audits no earlier than two years after the completion of those audits.

Where the client has received consultancy from a body that has a relationship with the certification body, that too is a significant threat. Recognized minimization: certification no earlier than two years after the end of the consultancy on that management system.

Audits may not be outsourced to a management system consultancy organization. That would be a threat that is not acceptable. Persons who are under contract as auditors are not what is meant by this. Clause 7.3 and the note to 7.5 deal with the individual contract separately.

Certification activities may not be marketed or offered together with consultancy on management systems. The body shall be able to correct inappropriate links or statements by a consultancy organization that present a certification as simpler, easier, faster or less expensive if this certification body were used. It may not itself make or imply such a statement if a particular consultancy organization were used.

Personnel who have provided management system consultancy to the client, including persons in a managerial position, may not be used in the audit or in other certification activities for that client. Recognized minimization: use no earlier than two years after the end of the consultancy.

A further hard boundary: a certification body may not certify the quality management system of another certification body. The standard speaks here of the quality management system, not indiscriminately of every management system.

Liability, money, structure

The body shall be able to demonstrate that it has assessed the risks arising from its certification activities and that it has suitable arrangements, for example insurance or reserves, to cover liabilities in the regions in which it operates. It shall determine its finances and sources of income and demonstrate that commercial, financial or other pressure does not jeopardize impartiality at the outset and on an ongoing basis.

The organizational structure, and the duties, responsibilities and authorities of management, of the personnel involved in certification and of all committees, shall be documented. Where the body is only a part of a legal entity, the structure shall show the chain of command and the relationships to other parts of the same legal entity. The activities shall be structured and managed so that impartiality is ensured.

Top management, as a committee, a group or a person, shall have overall authority and responsibility for: development of rules and establishment of processes; monitoring of their implementation; safeguarding of impartiality; monitoring of the finances; development of certification services and schemes; conduct of audits and certifications and handling of complaints; certification decisions; delegation to committees or persons; contractual arrangements; sufficient resources. For every committee that is involved in the certification activities, formal rules are needed on its establishment, its terms of reference and its way of working.

Branch offices, partnerships, representatives, franchisees and the like shall be effectively controlled, irrespective of legal status, relationship or location. The risk to competence, consistency and impartiality shall be taken into account. The degree of control takes into account processes, technical areas, competence of the personnel, chains of control, reporting and remote access to activities, including records.

Not in this text: an assessment of whether a specific ownership relationship of ICB triggers the two-year period. That can be decided only on the individual case and on the body's documented risk assessment. The standard names the two-year period as a recognized minimization of the threats described, not as a blanket waiting time for every previous contact.