logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

ISO 14001:2026

14001-15 Evaluation of compliance

3 min read · IA, EA, V

All articles

For: IA, EA, V
Source: ISO 14001:2026(en), fourth edition, English. 6.1.3, 9.1.2, 10.2 insofar as the connection, A.9.1.2, A.5.2 insofar as the connection

9.1.2 is a process of its own alongside 9.1.1. The organization shall establish, implement and maintain the processes needed to evaluate whether it fulfils its compliance obligations. It shall:

  • determine the frequency with which compliance is evaluated;
  • evaluate compliance and, where necessary, take action;
  • maintain knowledge and understanding of its compliance status.

Compliance obligations are legal requirements that it shall comply with, and other requirements that it shall comply with or that it has decided to comply with. They are determined and made accessible according to 6.1.3, explained in 14001-07. The environmental policy contains the commitment to fulfil them.

A.9.1.2 explains, as guidance, how the organization determines the periodic evaluation. Frequency and timing can differ according to the importance of the requirement, according to variations in operating conditions, according to changes in the compliance obligations and according to performance to date. According to this note, all compliance obligations shall be evaluated periodically. The English sentence of the guidance reads “all compliance obligations have to be evaluated periodically”. The organization can use results of evaluations by external parties as part of its process. If the results show that a compliance obligation is not fulfilled, it determines and implements the actions needed to achieve compliance. That can require communication with an authority and an agreement on the course of action. Where such an agreement exists, it becomes a compliance obligation.

Two sentences of the guidance carry the distinction that auditors otherwise easily draw. A.1 says that the Annex does not change the requirements. The sentences explain the connection between 9.1.2 and 10.2:

A non-compliance is not necessarily elevated to a nonconformity if, for example, it is identified and corrected by the environmental management system processes.

Compliance-related nonconformities have to be corrected, even if those nonconformities have not resulted in actual non-compliance with compliance obligations.

A non-compliance is not necessarily elevated to a nonconformity if, for example, it is identified and corrected by the processes of the environmental management system. Nonconformities related to compliance shall be corrected, even if they have not led to an actual non-compliance with the compliance obligations. What is to be done in the case of a nonconformity is set out in 10.2, explained in 14001-17. 3.4.3 says in a note that a nonconformity relates to requirements of this document and to additional requirements for the environmental management system that the organization sets for itself.

A.5.2 connects, as a reading aid, the commitment in the policy with the determination of the compliance obligations, with operation in accordance with them, with the periodic evaluation and with the correction of associated nonconformities. Those are the existing clauses 6.1.3, 8.1, 9.1.2 and 10.2, not a new obligation.

Documented information: Appropriate documented information shall be available as evidence of the result or the results of the evaluations of compliance. That is different evidence from the evidence of the monitoring and measurement results in 9.1.1.

Not in this text: a legal register, an authority, and the statement that every non-compliance is automatically a nonconformity. A.9.1.2 draws the distinction as guidance. The requirement remains 9.1.2 together with 10.2 when a nonconformity is present.