logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

ISO/IEC 17021-1

17021-18 Appeals, complaints, records

4 min read · V, EA

All articles

For: V, EA
Source: 9.7, 9.8, 9.9, 8.1.1 e), 8.4

Appeals

There shall be a documented process for receiving appeals, evaluating them and taking decisions on them. The body is responsible for all decisions at all levels of this process. The persons who deal with the appeal shall be persons other than those who carried out the audits and those who took the certification decisions. Submission, investigation and the decision may not disadvantage the appellant.

The process shall contain at least: an outline of receipt, validation and investigation, and of the decision on which measures are taken in response, taking earlier similar appeals into account; tracking and recording, including the measures taken to resolve the matter; ensuring that corrections and corrective actions are taken.

The body that receives the appeal gathers and verifies all the information needed in order to validate it. It shall acknowledge receipt and shall provide the appellant with progress reports and with the outcome. The decision communicated to the appellant shall be taken, or evaluated and approved, by persons who were not previously involved in the matter that underlies it. Completion shall be communicated formally to the appellant.

Complaints

The body is responsible for all decisions at all levels of the complaints process. Submission, investigation and the decision may not disadvantage the complainant. On receipt, the body shall confirm whether the complaint concerns certification activities for which it is responsible, and shall then deal with it. Where the complaint concerns a certified client, the investigation shall take the effectiveness of the certified system into account. The body shall pass justified complaints about a certified client on to that client within a reasonable time.

The documented process for receipt, evaluation and decision is subject to the confidentiality requirements, insofar as it concerns the complainant and the subject of the complaint. It shall contain at least: an outline of receipt, validation and investigation, and of the decision on measures; tracking and recording, including the responses; ensuring that appropriate corrections and corrective actions are taken. A note refers to ISO 10002 as guidance. This standard is not available here.

The body that receives the complaint gathers and verifies the information needed for validation. Wherever possible, it acknowledges receipt and provides progress and the outcome. The decision to be communicated shall be taken, or evaluated and approved, by persons who were not previously involved in the subject of the complaint. Wherever possible, a formal notification is given at the end. Together with the certified client and the complainant, the body shall determine whether, and to what extent, the subject and the resolution shall be made public.

The public list under 8.1.1 shall contain the procedure for requests for information, for complaints and for appeals. Information that originates from complainants shall be treated as confidential under 8.4.5, consistent with the body's policy.

Records on clients

Records of the audits and of the other certification activities shall be kept for all clients, including organizations that have submitted applications, that have been audited or certified, or whose certification has been suspended or withdrawn.

Records of certified clients shall contain: the application information and the reports on the initial, surveillance and recertification audits; the certification agreement; the justification of the sampling method at sites, where appropriate, including the sample used to select sites; the justification of the audit time; the verification of corrections and corrective actions; records of complaints and appeals and of any subsequent corrections or corrective actions; committee deliberations and decisions, where applicable; the documentation of the certification decisions; the certification documents, including the scope for the product, process or service, as far as applicable; related records that support credibility, for example evidence of the competence of auditors and technical experts; the audit programmes.

Records on applicants and clients shall be retained securely. Transport, sending or transfer shall maintain confidentiality. The policy and the procedures for retention shall be documented. Records of certified clients and of former certified clients shall be retained for the duration of the current cycle plus one further complete certification cycle. A note points out that, in some jurisdictions, a longer retention can be required by law.

Not in this text: a statement that every appeal leads to the decision being set aside, or that every complaint is published. Publication of the subject and of the resolution is the result of the joint determination under 9.8.11, not the usual case. ISO 10002 is not retold.