logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

ISO/IEC 27006:2015

27006-02 Competence and evidence

9 min read · EA

All articles

Version note. In the document itself, ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 and ISO/IEC 27001:2013 are the normative references. Annex D reviews the controls of 27001:2013. Annex D is not applied to 27001:2022.

For: EA
Source: ISO/IEC 27006:2015(E), English. 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, Annex A (informative)

For Clause 7, ISO/IEC 17021-1 applies. The basic rules on criteria, evaluation, records, external auditors, technical experts and outsourcing are in 17021-05; the knowledge according to Annex A of ISO/IEC 17021-1 is in 17021-06. Only the IS addition is set out here. 7.4 Personnel records and 7.5 Outsourcing contain no IS addition.

IS 7.1.1 requires that the body be aware of the technological, legal and regulatory developments that are relevant to the ISMS of the client it is assessing. It shall specify the competence requirements for each certification function, as they are designated in Table A.1 of ISO/IEC 17021-1. It shall take into account all requirements from ISO/IEC 17021-1 and from 7.1.2 and 7.2.1 of this standard that are relevant to the technical ISMS areas determined by the body. A note says that Annex A of this standard summarizes the competence requirements for personnel in particular certification functions. Annex A is informative. A.1 says that Table A.1 summarizes knowledge and skills and is informative, because it only names the areas of knowledge and of skill for each function. The requirements stand in the main text. The table refers to them. Table A.1 is not copied out here.

IS 7.1.2.1.1 requires criteria by which the body reviews the background, the particular training or the briefing of the audit team members so that at least five items of knowledge are ensured. Knowledge of information security. Technical knowledge of the activity to be audited. Knowledge of management systems. Knowledge of the principles of auditing. Knowledge of monitoring, measurement, analysis and evaluation of the ISMS. Points a to e apply to all auditors in the team. The exception is the technical knowledge of the activity to be audited: that can be shared in the team. “Can”. A note on the principles of auditing refers to ISO 19011. This edition is not available and is not retold.

The audit team shall be able to trace indications of information security incidents in the client's ISMS back to the appropriate elements of the ISMS. The team shall have appropriate work experience and practical application of the points named. The parenthetical text says that this does not mean an auditor needs the full spectrum of experience across all areas of information security. “Needs”. The team as a whole shall have enough understanding and experience to cover the ISMS scope being audited. “Shall”.

IS 7.1.2.1.2 requires, of all members of the audit team collectively, knowledge of five subjects. The specific documentation structures, the hierarchy and the interrelationships of an ISMS. The tools, methods and techniques of information security management and their application. Information security risk assessment and risk management. The processes that apply to the ISMS. Current technology, where information security may be relevant or is a question. “May” stands in this last point as the possibility that information security is relevant. Each auditor shall fulfil the points on documentation structures, on risk assessment and risk management, and on the ISMS processes. Tools and current technology remain the collective requirement of the team.

IS 7.1.2.1.3 requires of auditors who audit an ISMS knowledge of all the requirements in ISO/IEC 27001. The sentence names no year. The dated normative reference in Clause 2 is ISO/IEC 27001:2013. Collectively, all members of the team shall have knowledge of all the controls in ISO/IEC 27002 and of their implementation and, where determined to be necessary, also of controls from sector-specific standards. The PDF groups these controls into fourteen points: information security policies; organization of information security; human resource security; asset management; access control, including authorization; cryptography; physical and environmental security; operations security, including IT services; communications security, including network security management and information transfer; acquisition, development and maintenance of systems; supplier relationships, including outsourced services; management of information security incidents; information security aspects of business continuity management, including redundancies; compliance, including reviews of information security. That is the list in this PDF. ISO/IEC 27002 is named in that sentence without a year and is not retold. The four theme groups of Annex A of the 2022 edition are not in this list.

IS 7.1.2.1.4 requires of auditors who audit an ISMS knowledge of the good practice and the procedures of information security in the sector, of the policies and the business requirements for information security, of the general concepts and practices of corporate governance and of the connection between policy, objectives and results, and of management processes and the associated terminology. A note says that these processes also include personnel management, internal and external communication and other relevant support processes.

IS 7.1.2.1.5 requires knowledge of the legal and regulatory requirements in the information security area concerned, in the geography and in the areas of responsibility. A note says that this knowledge does not mean an in-depth legal background. Further: information security risks relating to the business sector, the general terminology, processes and techniques of the client's business sector, and the relevant practices of the business sector. The point on the legal and regulatory requirements may be shared in the team. “May”. The clause names no particular law.

IS 7.1.2.1.6 requires, collectively of the auditors, knowledge of the effect of the organization's type, size, management, structure, functions and relationships on the development and implementation of the ISMS and on the certification activities, including outsourcing; of complex operations seen broadly; and of the legal and regulatory requirements that apply to the product or the service. The clause names no particular law.

IS 7.1.2.2 is added for leading the team. Team leaders shall fulfil the following, and that shall be demonstrated in audits under direction and supervision: the knowledge and skills to lead the certification audit process and the audit team, and evidence of the ability to communicate effectively, orally and in writing.

IS 7.1.2.3 applies to personnel who carry out the application review in order to determine the team competence that is needed, to select the members and to determine the audit time. This personnel shall know: the relevant ISMS standards and other normative documents used in the certification process; the general terminology, processes, techniques and risks of the client's business sector; the client's products, processes, types of organization, size, management, structure, functions and relationships, in their significance for the development and implementation of the ISMS and for the certification activities, including outsourced functions.

IS 7.1.2.4 applies to personnel who review audit reports and take certification decisions. They shall have knowledge that enables them to review the adequacy of the certification scope, and of changes to the scope and their effect on the effectiveness of the audit, in particular the continued applicability of the interfaces and dependencies that were identified and of the associated risks. In addition, they shall be familiar with management systems in general, with audit processes and procedures, and with audit principles, practices and techniques. They shall know the points from 7.1.2.1.2 on documentation structures, on risk assessment and risk management and on the ISMS processes, and the legal and regulatory requirements that are relevant to information security. They shall know the relevant ISMS standards and other normative documents of the certification process, the general terminology and the risks relating to the relevant practices of the business sector, and the client's products, processes, types of organization, size, management, structure, functions and relationships. The last point ends at the relationships. The longer formulation on the development and implementation of the ISMS stands with the application review in 7.1.2.3, not in this sentence.

IS 7.2 requires that the body demonstrate the auditors' knowledge and experience through recognized ISMS-specific qualifications, through registration as an auditor where applicable, through participation in ISMS training and the acquisition of the associated personal evidence, through up-to-date records of professional development, and through ISMS audits witnessed by another ISMS auditor.

IS 7.2.1.1 is added to 7.1.2.1. The criteria for selecting auditors shall ensure that each auditor has a professional education, or training at a level equivalent to higher education; has at least four years of full-time practical workplace experience in information technology, of which at least two years are in a role or function related to information security; has successfully completed at least five days of training whose scope covers ISMS audits and audit management; has gained experience of the whole process of assessing information security before taking on the responsibility of acting as an auditor; has relevant and current experience; and keeps current knowledge and current skills in information security and in auditing up to date through continuing professional development.

In the sentence on the experience before taking on the responsibility of an auditor there is a recommendation. This experience should have been gained through participation in at least four ISMS certification audits, including recertification and surveillance audits, for a total of at least 20 days, of which at most 5 days may come from surveillance audits. “Should” applies to the four audits, the 20 days and the upper limit of 5 days. “May” applies to the share that comes from surveillance. A “shall” follows: the participation shall include the review of the documentation and of the risk assessment, the assessment of the implementation, and the audit reporting.

Technical experts shall fulfil the criteria on education, on the four years of practice with two years in information security, and on relevant and current experience. For them, the sentence does not name the five days of training, the experience before taking on the responsibility of an auditor, or the continuing professional development.

IS 7.2.1.2 is added to 7.1.2.2 and to 7.2.1.1. The criteria for selecting an auditor to lead the team shall ensure that this auditor has taken an active part in all stages of at least three ISMS audits. The participation shall include the initial determination of the scope and the planning, the review of the documentation and of the risk assessment, the assessment of the implementation, and the formal audit reporting. The three stands in this “shall”.

IS 7.3 says: technical experts shall work under the supervision of an auditor. The minimum requirements for technical experts are set out in 7.2.1.1, that is the criteria named there for technical experts. The heading of 7.3 names external auditors and external technical experts. The IS sentence itself speaks of the technical experts. For the use of individual external auditors, ISO/IEC 17021-1, 7.3, applies for the rest, with no further IS sentence.

Records: IS 7.2 names up-to-date records of professional development as one of the ways by which the body demonstrates the auditors' knowledge and experience. Which personnel records ISO/IEC 17021-1, 7.4, requires is set out in 17021-05. This PDF sets no IS text on that.

Not in this text: a copy of Table A.1, a transfer of the fourteen groups onto Annex A of ISO/IEC 27001:2022, the content of ISO/IEC 27002 and of ISO 19011, and a reading that makes a shall-threshold out of the four audits, the 20 days and the at most five surveillance days. The wording for that is “should”.