logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

ISO/IEC 42001:2023

42001-21 What auditors may read as a requirement

3 min read · EA, IA

All articles

For: EA, IA
Source: ISO/IEC 42001:2023(en), English. Headings of the annexes, A.1, B.1, C.1, D.1, 6.1.3

Normative are the requirements in clauses 4 to 10, the reference controls in Annex A, Table A.1, and Annex B as implementation guidance for these controls. Informative are Annex C and Annex D.

A.1 says that the controls in Table A.1 are a reference for meeting organizational objectives and for addressing risks related to the design and operation of AI systems. Not all objectives and controls of the table need be used. The organization can design its own controls, see 6.1.3.

6.1.3 requires the necessary controls to be determined, them to be compared with Annex A so that no necessary control is missing, relevant controls from Annex A to be considered, additional controls beyond Annex A to be identified where they are necessary, and the guidance in Annex B to be considered. The statement of applicability contains the necessary controls and the justification for inclusion and exclusion. A missing row from Table A.1 is therefore not already a nonconformity. A necessary control without inclusion and without a justified exclusion contradicts 6.1.3. Note 2 to 3.26 says, with “shall”, that all risks identified and the measures determined for their treatment are reflected in the statement.

B.1 says that the implementation guidance supports implementation and the meeting of the control objective. The organization need not document or justify, in the statement of applicability, the inclusion or exclusion of the implementation guidance. The guidance is not always suitable or sufficient and does not always meet the specific requirements of the organization. The organization can extend it, change it or establish an implementation of its own. Further organizational and technical measures can be determined. Annex B can count as a starting point.

The boxes “Control” in Annex B repeat the controls from Table A.1 predominantly with “should”, while Table A.1 uses “shall”. The requirement is the wording in Table A.1, to the extent the control is necessary. The recommendations and catalogues of examples in the implementation guidance are not turned into further “shall” sentences. B.7.6 retains “shall” in the box. In A.6.2.6, after the “shall” to define and document the necessary operational elements, there is a “should” for the minimum of monitoring, repair, updating and support. The “should” remains a recommendation in the sentence.

C.1 says that Annex C is not intended to be exhaustive or applicable to every organization. The names in C.2 and C.3 are possible objectives and risk sources. A missing treatment of one of these names is not a nonconformity arising from Annex C. D.1 and D.2 describe use across sectors and together with other management system standards. “Can” and “should” there do not justify an obligation to introduce a further standard.

The introduction says that the order of the requirements reflects neither importance nor the order of implementation. Lists are numbered only for reference.

Not in this text: an audit checklist from Annex B or Annex C, audit time, and the content of the standards in the bibliography. ISO/IEC 22989:2022 is the normative reference for terms. That edition is not available. What is defined only there is not supplemented from memory in an audit against this PDF.