Explanations of ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015
Source is the bilingual edition DIN EN ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015-11 (EN ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015). The German text of the standard is the language…
Read articleISO/IEC 17021-1
For: EA
Source: 4.3, Clause 7, Annex B, Annex C
Competence is the ability to apply knowledge and skills in order to achieve intended results. The body shall have processes that ensure that the personnel have appropriate knowledge and appropriate skills for the types of management systems and the geographical areas in which it operates.
There shall be a process that specifies the competence criteria for personnel involved in the management and the conduct of audits and other certification activities. The criteria shall be determined for each technical area and each function, taking into account the requirements of all standards or specifications of the respective type of management system. The result is documented criteria for the knowledge and the skills that are needed in order to carry out the tasks effectively and with the intended results.
Annex A is normative and specifies the kinds of knowledge and skills that shall be determined for particular functions. The content is in 17021-06. Where additional competence criteria are specified for a standard or a scheme, they shall be applied. The standard names as examples ISO/IEC TS 17021-2, ISO/IEC TS 17021-3 and ISO/TS 22003. These documents are not available here.
A note explains “technical area”: for all management systems it relates to products, processes and services in the context of the scope of the management system standard. A scheme can specify it, or the body determines it. Other usual words are scopes, categories, sectors.
For the initial evaluation and the ongoing monitoring of the competence and performance of all the personnel involved, documented processes are needed. The specified criteria shall be applied. The body shall demonstrate that its evaluation methods are effective. Persons who have demonstrated the required level shall be identified. The evidence shall be available before the person takes on responsibility for the activities.
Annex B is informative. It gives examples and creates no requirement of its own. It arranges methods in five categories: review of records, feedback, interviews, observations, examinations. One method alone will probably not confirm competence. The methods become more effective when they are aligned with the criteria from 7.1.2 and 7.1.3. Records such as curricula vitae, audit reports or evidence of training are indicators, and rarely evidence on their own. A report on the observed performance of an auditor can be direct evidence. Feedback from employers, personal references, peers or clients can be indicators, and each has the limits described in B.3. Feedback alone is not sufficient evidence. Interviews, including after an observed audit or on the basis of the report, can make decisions and audit trails traceable and can show linguistic and interpersonal abilities. Observation while carrying out the task provides direct evidence and is useful for administrative and management personnel, for auditors and for personnel who take decisions. Periodic observation confirms that competence is maintained. Written, oral and practical examinations can show knowledge and, depending on their design, skills. Examples of practical examinations: role plays, case studies, stress simulation, direct work situations.
Annex C is also informative. Figure C.1 shows an example of a sequence: name the tasks, name the knowledge and the skills needed for them, use the methods from Annex B. The figure creates no obligation to introduce exactly these boxes.
The body shall have access to technical expertise for advice on matters that directly concern the certification in all of its technical areas, types of management system and geographical areas. The advice may come from outside or from the body's own personnel.
There shall be sufficient competent personnel for the type and extent of the audit programmes and for the further certification tasks. Sufficient auditors, including audit team leaders and technical experts, shall be employed or accessible in order to cover all activities and the volume of audits. Every person involved shall understand their duties, responsibilities and authorities.
Processes shall govern the selection, training and formal authorization of auditors and the selection and briefing of technical experts. The initial competence evaluation of an auditor shall include the evidence that the auditor can apply the required knowledge and the required skills during audits. A competent evaluator establishes this by observing the auditor during an audit. A note permits desired behaviours to be considered in the selection and training process. Annex D describes them. It is informative; see 17021-07.
There shall be a process for achieving and demonstrating effective auditing, with general skills and knowledge and with skills and knowledge for particular technical fields. Auditors and, where required, technical experts shall be kept informed of audit processes, certification requirements and other relevant requirements, and shall have access to an up-to-date set of documented procedures and to relevant information. Training needs shall be identified, and specific training shall be offered or provided, so that auditors, technical experts and other personnel involved are competent for their tasks.
The performance of all persons engaged in audit and other certification activities shall be ensured. A documented monitoring process draws on the frequency of deployment and the degree of risk of the activities. Competence shall be evaluated and documented with regard to performance, in order to identify training needs.
Every auditor shall be monitored for every type of management system for which the auditor is considered competent. The documented process shall combine on-site evaluation, review of the audit reports and feedback from clients or from the market. The monitoring shall be designed so that disturbance of the normal certification processes remains slight, especially from the client's point of view. The performance of every auditor shall be evaluated on site at regular intervals. The frequency of these on-site evaluations draws on the need determined from all the monitoring information.
A written agreement shall be required of external auditors and external technical experts. In it they commit themselves to complying with the rules and processes of the body. The agreement shall address confidentiality and impartiality. The persons shall notify the body of all existing or former relationships to any organization for which they could carry out an audit. A note makes clear: engaging an individual person, or an employee of another organization, under an individual contract is not outsourcing.
Records on the personnel shall be kept up to date and shall cover relevant qualifications, training, experience, affiliations, professional status and competence, including management and administrative personnel.
Outsourcing is a subcontract with another organization that provides parts of the certification activities on behalf of the body. The standard uses “subcontracting” as a synonym. There shall be a process that describes the conditions under which this may take place, and a legally enforceable agreement with every such body covering conduct, confidentiality and conflicts of interest. The certification body remains responsible, ensures that the body and the personnel conform to its requirements and to the applicable provisions of this part, including competence, impartiality and confidentiality, and ensures that these persons are not involved in the organization to be audited in such a way that impartiality could be jeopardized. Authorization and monitoring of all outsourced bodies shall be arranged, and records of the competence of all the personnel involved shall be maintained. Decisions on certification status may not be outsourced.
Not in this text: quotas of hours, a minimum number of audits per year, or a template for the personnel file. The standard requires processes, criteria, evidence and records. It sets no number here. Scheme-specific criteria outside this document remain unaffected once they have been specified for the respective scheme.