Explanations of ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015
Source is the bilingual edition DIN EN ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015-11 (EN ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015). The German text of the standard is the language…
Read articleISO/IEC 17021-1
For: V, EA
Source: 4.4, 5.1.3, 7.2.8, 9.5, 9.6.1
The certification body shall be responsible for decisions on granting, refusing, maintaining, extending or reducing the scope, renewing, suspending, restoring after a suspension and withdrawing, and shall retain the sole right to those decisions. This right may not be outsourced. That is stated again in 7.5.2.
The persons or committees that decide on granting or refusing, extending or reducing, suspending or restoring, withdrawing or renewing shall be persons other than those who carried out the audits. They shall have the appropriate competence. Whoever takes the decision on granting, refusing, maintaining, renewing, suspending, restoring, withdrawing, extending or reducing shall understand the applicable standard and the certification requirements and shall have the demonstrated competence to evaluate the results of the audit process, including the recommendations of the audit team.
Persons who take a decision shall be employed by the body or by a body under its organizational control, or shall be subject to a legally enforceable agreement. Committee members under 6.1.4 are excepted from this sentence. Organizational control comprises full ownership of, or a majority holding in, another body, a majority holding in the management and control body of another body, or a documented authority over another body in a network of legal entities that are linked by ownership or by control of a management and control body. A note says that, in the case of governmental bodies, other parts of the same governmental body can be regarded as linked by ownership. Persons at controlled bodies shall fulfil the same requirements of this part as persons of the certification body.
Every decision is to be recorded, including additional information or clarifications requested from the audit team or from other sources.
Before the decision on granting, extending or reducing, renewing, suspending, restoring or withdrawing, a process shall ensure an effective evaluation. The information from the audit team shall be sufficient with regard to the requirements and the scope. For every major nonconformity, corrections and corrective actions shall have been evaluated, accepted and verified. For every minor nonconformity, the client's plan for corrections and corrective actions shall have been evaluated and accepted.
A major nonconformity affects the ability of the management system to achieve the intended results. A minor nonconformity does not affect that ability. The note to the term in 3.12 names cases in which classification as major comes into consideration: considerable doubt that effective process control exists or that products or services fulfil specified requirements; several minor nonconformities against the same requirement or the same problem that can represent a system-related failure. That is a note to the definition, not an exhaustive list.
For maintaining certification there is a narrowly described exception to the independent decision. The body may maintain the certification on a positive conclusion of the audit team leader, without further independent evaluation and decision, where two conditions are fulfilled. First: for every major nonconformity or other situation that could lead to suspension or withdrawal, the audit team leader shall report to the body that competent personnel need an evaluation. This personnel shall be different from the personnel who carried out the audit and shall have the competence according to 7.2.8. The evaluation shall determine whether the certification can be maintained. Second: competent personnel of the body review the surveillance activities, including the auditors' reporting, and confirm that the certification activities are carried out effectively.
Which information shall be available before initial certification and recertification is set out in 17021-15.
Not in this text: a statement that the audit team awards “passed” or “failed”. The team works out conclusions and a recommendation. The decision remains with the body, with the exception named only for maintaining certification.