logo
language iconarrow
menu icon

Across the management system standards

Q4 Leadership, policy, roles

6 min read · V

All articles

For: V
Source: Clause 5 of ISO 9001:2026, ISO 14001:2026, ISO 45001:2018, ISO/IEC 27001:2022 and ISO/IEC 42001:2023. ISO 45001 additionally 5.4.

Top management shall, in each of these standards, demonstrate leadership and commitment for its system. The lists are not the same list. None of them prescribes an organization chart.

ISO 9001:2026. In addition to integration into the business processes, the resources, communication, the intended results, the support of persons, continual improvement and the support of other roles, 5.1.1 requires four further points: promoting a quality culture and ethical behavior, promoting the process approach, promoting risk-based thinking and opportunity-based thinking, and taking accountability for the effectiveness. 5.1.2 is a requirement of its own on customer focus: determine, understand and continually fulfil customer requirements and applicable statutory and regulatory requirements; determine and address risks and opportunities that can affect conformity and the ability to enhance customer satisfaction; maintain the focus on enhancing customer satisfaction. 5.2 requires a policy that fits the purpose, provides a framework for quality objectives, includes the commitment to fulfil applicable requirements and to continual improvement, takes the context into account and supports the strategic direction. According to A.2, "takes into account" includes bringing the matter in. The policy shall be available as documented information, be communicated, be available to interested parties as appropriate, and be implemented, understood and applied. Alongside conformity of the system and reporting to top management, 5.3 assigns further responsibilities: that the processes deliver their intended results, that customer focus is promoted, that opportunities for improvement are reported, and that the integrity of the system is maintained when changes are planned and implemented. A.5.3 says, as guidance, that the roles could be distributed. The document does not prescribe a title "quality management representative" or a quality manual. The elaboration is in 9001-07.

ISO 14001:2026. 5.1 requires taking accountability for the effectiveness, aligning policy and objectives with the strategic direction and the context, integrating the requirements into the business processes, ensuring resources, communicating the importance, ensuring the intended results, directing persons, promoting continual improvement and supporting other roles. A requirement on quality culture, customer focus, the process approach or risk-based thinking does not stand in 5.1. A.3 says that "ensure" means responsibility can be transferred, accountability cannot. 5.2 requires the environmental policy to be established, implemented and maintained within the defined scope. It shall fit the purpose and context, including the nature, scale and environmental impacts, provide a framework for environmental objectives, and contain three commitments: protection of the environment, including prevention of pollution and other commitments relevant to the context; fulfilment of the compliance obligations; continual improvement in order to improve environmental performance. The note names climate protection and adaptation as a possible further commitment. "Can". The policy shall be available as documented information, be communicated within the organization and be available to interested parties. "As appropriate" does not stand at this place of availability to interested parties. 5.3 assigns two responsibilities: conformity of the system with this document, and reporting on performance, including environmental performance, to top management. The elaboration is in 14001-05.

ISO 45001:2018. 5.1 carries additional points that do not stand in the other standards of this comparison: overall responsibility for the prevention of work-related injury and ill health, a culture that supports the intended results, protection of workers from reprisals when reporting, processes for consultation and participation in accordance with 5.4, and support of OH&S committees. 5.2 requires a policy with commitments to safe and healthy working conditions, to the framework for the objectives, to fulfilling legal requirements and other requirements, to the elimination of hazards and the reduction of OH&S risks, to continual improvement, and to consultation and participation. The policy shall be available as documented information, be made known, be available to interested parties as appropriate, and be relevant and appropriate. 5.3 requires responsibilities and authorities to be assigned, made known at all levels and maintained as documented information. Workers at all levels shall take responsibility for the aspects within their area of influence. The two assigned leadership tasks are conformity of the system and reporting to top management. 5.4 is a clause of its own. Consultation, 3.5, is seeking views before the decision. Participation, 3.4, is involvement in the decision. The lists in 5.4 d and 5.4 e remain separate. The other management system standards in the folder do not have a clause 5.4 with these lists. The elaboration is in 45001-03 and 45001-04.

ISO/IEC 27001:2022. 5.1 has eight points, a to h: policy and objectives compatible with the strategic direction, integration into the processes of the organization, resources, communication of the importance, intended results, direction of persons, promotion of continual improvement, support of other leadership roles. Quality culture, customer focus, the process approach and risk-based thinking do not stand in 5.1. 5.2 requires a policy that is appropriate to the purpose, includes information security objectives or provides the framework for setting them, includes a commitment to applicable information security requirements and includes a commitment to continual improvement. Point b is an or. The sentence does not require both at the same time. The policy shall be available as documented information, be communicated and be available to interested parties as appropriate. 5.3 assigns two responsibilities: conformity of the system, and reporting on performance to top management. The note says that top management can also assign the reporting responsibility within the organization. "Can". The elaboration is in 27001-03.

ISO/IEC 42001:2023. 5.1 follows the same direction of eight points as ISO/IEC 27001, 5.1, applied to the AI policy, the AI objectives and the AI management system. Note 2 says that a culture with a responsible approach can be a sign of leadership. "Can". That is not a culture requirement with a "shall" of its own alongside the list. 5.2 requires a policy that is appropriate to the purpose, provides a framework for AI objectives, includes a commitment to fulfil applicable requirements, and includes a commitment to continual improvement. An or between "includes the objectives" and "provides the framework", as in ISO/IEC 27001, 5.2 b, does not stand here. The policy shall be available as documented information, refer to other policies where relevant, be communicated and be available to interested parties as appropriate. 5.2 counts as a requirement of chapters 4 to 10. Reference control A.2.2 applies only if it is necessary under 6.1.3. 5.3 assigns the two responsibilities: conformity of the system, and reporting on performance to top management. An obligation to maintain the roles in 5.3 as documented information does not stand there. It can arise if A.3.2 is necessary. The elaboration is in 42001-04.

Documented information: In each of the five standards, the policy shall be available as documented information. ISO 45001, 5.3, additionally requires responsibilities and authorities of relevant roles to be maintained as documented information. 5.1 and 5.3 of ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO/IEC 27001 and ISO/IEC 42001 do not require documented information of their own for the organization chart.

Not in this text: an organization chart, a model wording of the policy, and the transfer of 5.4, of 5.1.2 or of the quality culture onto a standard whose clause 5 does not contain these sentences.